Welcome to P.J. Whelihan's Pub Restaurant - Lancaster
P.J. Whelihan's Pub Restaurant in Lancaster, located on Fruitville Pike, offers a vibrant pub experience marked by delicious food and friendly service. Guests rave about the hot, tasty dishes, from customizable burgers to standout salads, like the strawberry salad featuring candied pecans. While the lively atmosphere, enhanced by numerous TVs for sports enthusiasts, can be quite loud, attentive staff like Gabby and Bri are dedicated to ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a place to unwind, P.J. Whelihan's balances a warm ambiance with flavorful offerings that cater to diverse palates.
P.J. Whelihan's Pub Restaurant - Lancaster: Reviews & Ratings
Great restaurant. Food hot and tasty. Staff very accommodating and friendly. I wish the location had more tables away from the bar so it is easier to talk to your dinner companions but it is a pub and that's the nature of the bar scene
Food was good. Service was great. Atmosphere was very loud. It was hard to carry on a conversation, but if you were there to hang out and watch sports on the various TV's, it was great.
There's no black and bleu burger on the menu here like my gma was hoping for, but our waitress let her build her own and she said it was perfect. The strawberry salad I had was superb, and everything came out quickly. The candied pecans topping my salad made us buy some the next day because of how good they were haha.
Gabby our sever was awesome. Took amazing care of us. Food was great
My family and I had dinner on Mother’s Day and our sever was Bri. I did not like what I ordered and she was so sweet and understanding and allowed me to get something else without making me feel uncomfortable. She made some great drink recommendations and was very knowledgeable about the entire menu. Bill the manager came and checked in on us and was so kind and genuinely wanted our opinion. He was great!!! We sat outside and it was just an overall great experience.
Went to PJ's the other day with friends for drinks.The drinks were amazing and so was our server, Riley. She was so kind, energetic, and helpful. Definitely coming back and hoping to have Riley are our server again!
Everything was amazing, my favorites were the Ancho steak street tacos and cheese curds. If you get Gabby as your waitress you're in for a treat, she's such a fun vibe and she's great with the recommendations!
This was my first time at PJ's and it was amazing! Riley was my server and she was super knowledgeable about the menu, super friendly, and provided amazing service. The food was also super yummy and they have good happy hour deals. I will definitely be back and will be requesting that Riley is my server!
Location
-
1569 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States Hotline: +1 717-205-4700
Welcome to P.J. Whelihan's Pub & Restaurant located in Lancaster, PA—an eatery known for its vibrant atmosphere, delectable food, and friendly service. Nestled at 1569 Fruitville Pike, this pub is not just a place to grab a bite; it’s an experience that delights both sports lovers and casual diners alike. With numerous TVs showcasing the latest games, the buzz of camaraderie fills the air, making it an ideal spot for gatherings with friends and family.
The menu at P.J. Whelihan's is a selection of classics that never fail to impress. While regulars may miss specific items like the black and bleu burger, the flexibility of the staff shines through. They are more than willing to accommodate requests, ensuring that each dining experience is personalized and satisfying. Diners rave about the strawberry salad, a mix of fresh ingredients topped with candied pecans that has diners coming back for more—even to the point of purchasing toppings to recreate the dish at home!
The reviews consistently highlight the commitment of the staff, with patrons recalling their experiences with waiters who go above and beyond—for example, Gabby and Bri, who are mentioned for their attentiveness and drink recommendations. Such interactions create a welcoming environment that elevates your dining experience, making it feel less like a meal and more like an outing with friends.
While P.J. Whelihan’s can get a bit noisy—exit conversations may feel challenging—you may find that the lively atmosphere adds to the pub's charm. After all, if you're here to enjoy hearty dishes and watch the game, the energetic soundscape only enhances the enjoyment. Just as one reviewer said, if you're looking to hang out and indulge in good food with friends while cheering for your team, this is the place to be.
In summary, P.J. Whelihan's Pub & Restaurant in Lancaster is a testament to excellent service, tasty food, and a spirited ambiance. It’s a perfect destination for those looking to enjoy a satisfying meal amidst the thrill of sports. Don’t miss your chance to experience everything this inviting pub has to offer!